Since I was young, I've felt deeply the importance of remembering the Holocaust. I've spent a long time reading about it, studying it; it is something that is important to me. Auschwitz was somewhere that I've always wanted to see--maybe 'wanted' is the wrong word--it is somewhere I felt I needed to see. Roo knows this, which is why he suggested we go to Poland. I couldn't believe he was up for it, but of course I felt like I should go and was happy he was willing to go as well.
It was our second day in Poland. We slept in, had a nice breakfast, then headed out. As we drove, I was somewhat surprised by the feelings churning in my head. I actually felt nervous. I felt antsy. I felt dread. On the plane, I had started reading a book called Alicia: My Story, one of the most heart-rending Holocaust memoirs I'd ever read. So I suppose my mind was fresh with the horrors of that time. I couldn't really talk as we passed through a series of sad, dilapidated towns that blended into black and white forests--the kind of forests where the terrible things I'd read about had happened.
My only other experience with visiting a concentration camp was when we went to Dachau in July. I guess that set my expectations. Dachau, though it had been a horrible place in its time, was now well-run by its current German administrators--it had an airy, modern visitors' center of glass and stone. The camp was quiet and not much remained besides rows of foundations. It was a bright day. I toured the place with a melancholy fascination. It had a feeling of long-removed sadness, like a memorial, like a cemetery. It was not a scary place. I was hoping to find something similar in Auschwitz, but the closer we came, the more I knew that would not be the case.
Auschwitz is actually made up of two separate camps; the first was more of a work camp, the inmates slept in multiple story brick barracks with doors and windows--where they had a minimal chance of survival--minimal, but still a chance. The second camp (Birkenau) was the place where people went to die--some immediately and some had to wait, but this place was not meant to allow for any survival. This was the place we came upon first.
We drove along an ordinary road until suddenly this gate, this structure that represents horror was just there, on the side of the main road.
Normally, tourists visit Birkenau after seeing the first camp. And since we were there in the morning, and most tourists were at the first camp, this place was almost completely empty. There was no gleaming visitors' center encouraging tolerance, hope, and remembrance. There were no employees. There were no fancy audio guides and brochures. We just walked through an old gate into the place, as if we were the first people to come upon it in a long time. And if we had been, if we had no idea what this place was, we would have easily guessed from its very infrastructure that it was an evil place.
First of all, it was huge. It was divided by a railway the cut through its center. Here was the unloading platform where one eerie rail car still stood, and on either side of the tracks, the camp stretched on and on. It would have taken hours to walk through it all. On one side were single-level, crumbling brick barracks whose doors were padlocked shut. On the other side were endless rows of dirty brick chimneys, the only remains of what were once wooded barracks--the kind you think of when you think about concentration camps. They stretched before us like some diabolical forest, still surrounded by high fences of barbed wire.
As we made our way around, not sure really where to go, I felt unable to process what I was seeing. This place stood not like a memorial to remembrance and tolerance, but like a massive scar that would never fade. It was a terrible place, and I felt terrible looking at it.
At the very rear of the camp, where the railway ended stood a massive raised platform, recently constructed, where a dark monument stood along with plaques like headstones carved with a message in all the languages of those who perished there. It read that this place would stand as a cry of despair for the ages. A cry of despair was right. From that raised platform, you could see into the underground gas chambers, now roof-less and exposed. You could see the ruined crematoriums, evidence of the crimes the Nazis hastily tried to cover up, to destroy before the world figured out what was going on. I felt overcome here and wandered awhile, just crying.
The walk out of the camp was long, it felt like miles. All I wanted to do was get out of there. I couldn't feel detached historical fascination; I could only feel disgust and horror.
We made our way over to the first Auschwitz camp, the work camp. Here were the tourists. They milled about in the dark, communist-feeling entry building, eating sandwiches and laughing. I geared up for more, and we started into the camp. After we walked outside, I found out we'd just left the building where prisoners were initially processed into the camp. I felt sick. From there we were confronted by a series of atrocities as we toured the museum displays set up in the former barracks. None of this was new to me. I'd read and seen all of it before, many times. But being there was completely different. It was oppressive. The building that housed the plunder of the Nazis was the hardest. There were mountains of human hair, suitcases, shoes, toothbrushes, bowls and plates. They belonged to individuals who suffered so much.
By the time we made it to the camp jail basement, I couldn't handle anymore atrocities and I had to get out. I walked as fast as I could to get away, passing (of course) the gas chamber on our way out.
I just wanted to get away from there. I didn't even want to take pictures. It felt too ugly, like it wasn't good enough for pictures.
It has taken a week or so, a week to get away from the shock of it, for me to process what I saw. I am very glad we went. I am thankful for the opportunity. I've felt more aware of the fact that it is simple things like love and kindness that keep the world from spinning out of control.
In the week since, I had to prepare a lesson on the Atonement for the girls at church. As I studied and read about it, I felt very aware of how unfathomable the amount of suffering Jesus Christ experienced was. I couldn't stop thinking about it--how much pain humans go through, and as a result, how much He also must have experienced. I don't understand fully what happens after we die or how things get sorted out, but I have to believe that God is a fair God, and that somehow, through the Atonement, all will be made right for everyone. Somehow. I need to believe that.
6 comments:
What a heavy, heavy post. I can feel the eeriness in the pictures and my heart hurts. I learned about the Holocaust three times growing up--it just happened to be what the teachers were teaching each time we moved states. It was terrible and I can't think about it too much or I feel so sick.
You are right though--somehow Christ's Atonement covers every single part of it, even the anguish we feel learning about it. Thank goodness we have such a merciful Heavenly Father to make all things right.
I'm so glad you are still writing. Beautifully conveyed, hauntingly described. It is a place I also have felt I have "needed" to go but I don't know if I'll ever get there so reading your thoughts are second best. You are a beautiful person, Miss Annie. Such beauty in such a desperate and loathsome place represents to me so much of the hope and redemption your heart searched for. There stood a woman, a strong woman of faith and courage, a mother who is instrumental in training two little girls how to think and act towards others. There, in that God-forsaken place, stood a woman who had learned for herself what kindness means and who Christ is. That, for me, is all the hope we need... that people like you visit places like that and look around in disgust... because that means we'll fight to make sure it never happens again. EVER.
Lizzie's comment is so beautiful and apt. Thank you for writing this, Annie. You did so beautifully. I kept thinking as I read it that it ought to be published somewhere. If that's at all interesting to you, I have some ideas that I'd be glad to write you about.
Holocaust. the very word makes my throat ache In Jerusalem I saw the memorial of the holocaust. I couldn't take it all in. My comfort is in the Book of Mormon where it tells that innocent sufferers are taken immediately to the bosom of Christ. I don't know what happens to the perpetrators of such horror but I would bet it isn't comfortable. Only the atonement of Christ can take out the sting of death.
This is Joel Wright and I am so grateful to be the father of Annie. Her heart and soul are friends to Christ and thus she finds horror in horrible places. Her Mother is the same. I have always been interested in the stories of war and the history of man's treatment of man. The draw for me has been what Annie's post and each of these other marvelous comments portray - namely that the goodness of the Best God - Jesus Christ is found in the amazing sacrifice of the most amazing big brother who came to the spiritual and physical rescue of us all. We study these terrible events and pause in silence for the sacrifice that makes all things right again. We also praise those men and women who answered the call to fight these wars and who, when they arrived at the gates of these camps to free the inmates, paused and pondered and said "this is why we fight!" This is why we are devoted to the Savior. He and our Father in Heaven wipe away all the tears and make all the bad go away. That is what good parents and good big brothers do. "You People" are all very amazing!
My beautiful Annie. I was so touched by what you wrote. I would have loved to have been with you. I went to Dachau with Grandpa, Mark, Soroya. The Germans had already made that place a tourist attraction. I have read the book you mentioned, and loved it. Actually I have read about 40 books on World War II. I can't get enough. I needed to understand this peculiar time in our history. I was 2 years old when it started and 8 when it ended. I heard more than I saw, but it was enough to prick my curiosity. You are so special to me Annie, and because of what you have seen and shared, you have become even closer to my heart. Thank you for sharing with your beautiful and elegant words. I love you so much, my sweet Annie. Give my love the two beautiful girls of yours and to our special Roo.
Tenderly, Granny Wright.
Post a Comment